Start / Catholic Answers Live / 12193 did pauls rebuke of peter undermine the papacy joe heschmeyer

#12193 Did Paul’s Rebuke of Peter Undermine the Papacy? - Joe Heschmeyer

N/A • 13 maj 2025

In Galatians, Paul publicly rebukes Peter—but does that disprove papal authority? We unpack what really happened in Antioch and why the Church still holds Peter as the first pope, even amid correction and scandal.

Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here

Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com

Questions Covered:

03:22 – Why do people object to the Pope’s role in the Church?
06:40 – Isn’t the papacy unbiblical and not meant to persist beyond Peter?
10:35 – Does the Bible ever say Peter was in Rome?
14:20 – What does “Babylon” mean in 1 Peter 5:13, and how is that connected to Rome?
17:15 – Didn’t Paul co-found the Church in Rome with Peter?
20:05 – Paul rebuked Peter—doesn’t that undermine papal authority?
25:18 – Was Peter’s behavior in Antioch heretical or just scandalous?
30:40 – Doesn’t Galatians 2 show Peter as just another apostle, not a leader?
34:25 – Why do Protestants say we don’t need a Pope if Jesus tore the temple veil?
39:12 – Does Jesus as sole mediator mean there’s no place for the Pope or priests?
43:50 – Why is Hebrews 10 crucial to properly understanding the torn temple veil?
47:00 – Is priesthood abolished in the New Testament?
50:10 – What does 1 Corinthians 10 tell us about sacrifice, the Eucharist, and priests?
54:45 – Why is there a structural Protestant objection to the papacy?

Senaste avsnitt

#12280 Can We Take Jesus Literally as the Bread of Life? Hell, Mercy, and Saints - Jimmy Akin

12 juli | min

#12279 Can Animals Go to Heaven? Popes, Salvation, and Scripture - Jimmy Akin

11 juli | min

#12278 What Is the Role of Popes in Approving Ecumenical Councils? - Alex Jurado

11 juli | min

#12277 What Is the Origin of the Hail Mary in Catholicism? - Colin Donovan

10 juli | min

#12276 Does Scripture Support Male-Only Authority? A Catholic Response - Joe Heschmeyer

10 juli | min

#12193 Did Paul’s Rebuke of Peter Undermine the Papacy? - Joe Heschmeyer

Senaste avsnitt

#12280 Can We Take Jesus Literally as the Bread of Life? Hell, Mercy, and Saints - Jimmy Akin

#12279 Can Animals Go to Heaven? Popes, Salvation, and Scripture - Jimmy Akin

#12278 What Is the Role of Popes in Approving Ecumenical Councils? - Alex Jurado

#12277 What Is the Origin of the Hail Mary in Catholicism? - Colin Donovan

#12276 Does Scripture Support Male-Only Authority? A Catholic Response - Joe Heschmeyer

#12275 Can You Attend a Catholic’s Invalid Wedding? Moral Theology Explained - Joe Heschmeyer

#12272 Do Muslims Worship the Same God? Catholic View on Islam and Faith - Karlo Broussard

#12273 What Are the Real Criteria for Mortal Sin? A Catholic Breakdown - Karlo Broussard

#12272 Was Christ Made Sin? Catholic View vs. Calvinist Atonement - Mark Brumley

#12271 Catholic Perspective on Teen Consent, IVF, and Artificial Pregnancy - Fr. Tad Pacholczyk

#12270 Why Do Priests Receive Both Species? Eucharist, Communion, and Jesus’ Command Explained - Jimmy Akin

#12269 Fourth of July Mysteries, Mortal Sin After Baptism, and Genesis vs. Ancient Myths - Jimmy Akin

#12268 How to Start a Career in Catholic Apologetics, Plus Ad Orientem Mass and Exorcism Explained - Tim Staples

#12267 Understanding Transubstantiation, Vatican II Liturgy Changes, and the Inquisition Explained - William Albrecht

#12266 Liturgy of the Hours, Infant Baptism vs Circumcision, and Patron Saints Explained - Joe Heschmeyer

#12265 Catholic vs LDS Beliefs, Purgatory Explained, and Why Only Priests Drink the Wine at Mass - Steve Ray

#12264 Early Church Writings, Marian Apparitions in Egypt, and Salvation Through the Catholic Church - Karlo Broussard

#12263 Catholic Teaching on Cremated Ashes, Saints’ Relics, and Infant Baptism - Karlo Broussard

#12262 Mortal Sin, Confession, Miracles, Fairies, and the Role of the Cantor at Mass - Joe Heschmeyer

#12261 Exodus 21:7-11, Toddlers at Mass, Islam, Evolution, and World History - Joe Heschmeyer

#12260 Why the Church Introduced the Novus Ordo & Why Have Both Forms - Jimmy Akin

#12259 Did John Know About the Other Gospels When He Wrote His? - Jimmy Akin

#12258 Young Catholics on Fire: How the Eucharistic Pilgrimage Is Changing Lives - Cy Kellett

#12257 Bishop Earl Fernandes on Education and the Role of the Church in Society - Cy Kellett

#12256 Resurrection Facts, Reality Shifting Morality, and the Church’s View on Firearms - Jimmy Akin

#12255 Can You Name Your Guardian Angel? Plus Tongues, Communion, and Eucharist by Drone - Jimmy Akin

#12254 Catholic Doctrine Explained: Eucharist, Baptism, and Scriptural Challenges - Karlo Broussard

#12253 Is the Mass a Sacrifice? Understanding the Eucharist and Mary’s Assumption - Karlo Broussard

#12252 Church Authority Explained: Bishop of Rome, Magisterium, and Catholic Teaching - Joe Heschmeyer

#12251 Catholic Teaching on Divorce, Communion, Suicide, and the Church Fathers Explained - Joe Heschmeyer

#12250 Resurrection, Original Sin, and the Trinity: Tough Catholic Questions Answered - Jimmy Akin

#12249 From the Early Church to Calvary: Catholic Insights on Worship, Recovery, and Scripture - Jimmy Akin

#12248 Wrestling with God’s Love: Sacraments, Grace, and Jacob’s Struggle - Tim Staples

#12247 Faith Working Through Love: Salvation, Confession, and Trusting the Church - Alex Jurado

#12246 Culture and Conversion: What’s Drawing People to Catholicism Today? ⎮Flannel Panel - Christopher Check

#12245 World War II, Modern Warfare, SpaceX, Transgender Issues, and more │ Flannel Panel - Joe Heschmeyer

#12244 What the Catholic Church Teaches on Evolution, Adam & Eve, and More - Karlo Broussard

#12243 Understanding Catholic Doctrine: Sin, Justification, and the Sacraments with Karlo Broussard - Karlo Broussard

#12242 Pope Leo XIV: The First American Pope – Behind the Scenes with Dr. Matthew Bunson - Matthew E. Bunson

#12241 Can Saints Speak to Us? And Other Questions Catholics Are Asking - Fr. Paul Keller O.P.

#12240 Doctrinal Development vs. Public Revelation: What the Church Really Teaches - Jimmy Akin

#12239 Did Martin Luther seek Self-Justification? Catholic Perspective on the Reformation - Jimmy Akin

#12238 Can You Divide Ashes? Catholic Teaching on Relics, Cremation, and Organ Donation - Tim Staples

#12237 The Eucharist: Sacrifice, OCIA, and Public Witness and more - null

#12236 Catholic Help for Addiction, Faith-Based Recovery That Works - Scott Weeman

#12235 Unity, the Fruits of the Spirit, and Responding to Protestant Objections - Joe Heschmeyer

#12234 Was Mary Really Immaculately Conceived? Could Jesus Be Born of a Sinner? - Karlo Broussard

#12233 Holy Spirit, Mary, Saints, and Indulgences—What Catholics Really Believe - Karlo Broussard

#12232 When Should You Admit You Struggle with Chastity in a Relationship? - Jason Evert

#12231 Are Temperaments Fixed or Fluid? Catholic Answers to Personality Questions - Rose Sweet

#12230 Why Didn’t Jesus Write a Gospel? & More Weird Questions - Jimmy Akin

#12229 Do You Need to Confess Sins from a Time Loop? & More Weird Questions - Jimmy Akin

#12228 Did Anyone Recognize Jesus from His Childhood at the Temple? - Tim Staples

#12227 Why Orthodox & Catholics Differ on Union with God & Church Authority - William Albrecht

#12226 Can Receive Communion at Orthodox Churches, but Not Anglican Ones? - Joe Heschmeyer

#12225 Why Isn’t the Book of Enoch in the Bible If the Disciples Referenced It? - Joe Heschmeyer

#12224 How to Talk About Converting When Your Spouse Isn’t Open to the Faith - Jim Blackburn

#12223 Did St. Jerome Reject the Catholic Bible? Responding to Protestant Claims - Alex Jurado

#12222 Catholic Answers to Suicide, Guilt, and Mental Health Struggles - Dr. Greg Bottaro

#12221 Catholic Dating Advice: Can It Work with a Non-Denominational Christian? - Steve Ray

#12220 Did the Church Ever Teach Reincarnation? And More Questions - Jimmy Akin

#12219 Is It Catholic to Oppose Abortion but Not Its Criminalization? - Jimmy Akin

#12218 From Islam to Catholicism – Interview with Dr. Jacob Imam - Jacob Imam

#12217 Building Catholic Companies in the Secular World - Nick Madden

#12216 Should We Pray to the Saints? A Scriptural and Historical Defense - Karlo Broussard

#12215 Do the Saints Hear Us? A Biblical Defense of Intercessory Prayer - Karlo Broussard

#12214 Is Confirmation Really in the Bible? And More - Tom Nash

#12213 Understanding Catholic Social Teaching From Pope Leo XIII to Today - Tom Nash

#12212 What Are the Consequences of Having an American Pope? | Flannel Panel - Joe Heschmeyer

#12211 Will Pope Leo Shape the Church’s Response to AI? | Flannel Panel - Christopher Check

#122010 What If You Pray and Still Feel No Response From God? - Jimmy Akin

#12209 Why Does the Church Celebrate Marian Apparitions If They’re Private Revelation? - Jimmy Akin

#12208 How Do We Know God Is the One and Only Almighty Creator? - Tim Staples

#12207 What Does ‘Imputed Righteousness of Christ’ Mean in Catholic Teaching? - Jimmy Akin

#12206 Did Jesus’ ‘I Am’ Statements Really Mean He Claimed to Be God? - Joe Heschmeyer

#12205 What Sets Catholicism Apart from Other Abrahamic Faiths? - Tim Staples

#12204 Does Calling Peter the Rock Contradict Deuteronomy? - Tim Staples

#12203 Is the Sacrifice of the Mass Symbolic or the Real Sacrifice of Jesus? - Karlo Broussard