44 Years in Darkness

Tonight, Sylvia Shultz joins me to discuss how a woman spent 44 years of her life locked away in a utica crib to the point of scratching her eyes out, pulling her teeth, loosing the ability to speak and resembling a skeletal figure...covered in rags. The mindset of care takers in those early days was truly bizarre!Tonight, Sylvia Shults returns with the haunting true story of Rhoda Derry—a woman locked in a Utica crib for over 40 years, left to waste away in madness after being "cursed" for falling in love.

Abandoned at the Adams County Poor Farm, Rhoda clawed out her own eyes, pulled her teeth, and lived in a wooden box, forgotten by the world.

Her heartbreaking journey from torment to eventual peace at the Peoria State Hospital is one of the darkest—and most powerful—tales in the history of American asylums.

This is not just a ghost story… it’s a tragedy that echoes through time.

Lost in the shadows of Illinois asylums in the nineteenth century is the strange story of Rhoda Derry. Left at the Adams County Poor Farm when her family could no longer care for her, she spent the next 40 years confined in a wooden box. Abandoned, ignored, and traumatized, she had clawed out her own eyes, pulled her own teeth, and her legs were atrophied to the point that she could not stand on her own, or even sit in a wheelchair. She spent four decades locked away from the world. Her crime? Falling in love.   Rhoda suffered a mental breakdown after being "cursed" by the mother of a boy to whom she was engaged to marry. Committed to the poor farm because of her violent insanity, she was eventually rescued by pioneering alienist Dr. George A. Zeller. She was taken to the Peoria State Hospital in Bartonville, Illinois, where she spent the remainder of her days in comfort. Rhoda died in 1906, but her spirit lives on at the former asylum where she found peace.    The chilling story of Rhoda Derry is one of the great tragedies of mental health care in Illinois, but one of the great success stories of the Peoria State Hospital. Sylvia Shults, author of Fractured Spirits: Hauntings at the Peoria State Hospital, returns to the hilltop to tell the story of Rhoda's life -- and her mysterious afterlife.

Unlock a world of mystery!

Join our exclusive community and instantly access over 1,000 ad-free episodes, mind-blowing bonus segments, and much more. Dive deeper into the unknown with content that challenges what you think you know.

For nearly a decade, Mysterious Radio has taken listeners on a journey through the strange, the unexplained, and the downright chilling. And now, we're taking things to the next level—with even more immersive content available only to our most dedicated listeners.

With millions of listeners around the globe, the next era of Mysterious Radio is unfolding. The majority of episodes and exclusives will be reserved for our inner circle of members.

Step beyond the veil and claim your place in the next chapter of the unknown. 

Do you frequently miss episodes of Mysterious Radio? Don't worry; here are some tips to ensure you never miss out again:

1. If you haven't already, follow or subscribe to the show to receive updates on new episodes. Even if you have already done this, it's a good idea to click the option again to ensure that you are still subscribed. This is especially important!

2. Turn on notifications for new episodes in your podcast app.

3. Make sure that your device allows notifications from your podcast app.

4. If your app has the option, swipe down to refresh the list of episodes.