In this bonus episode of Podcast Portwenn, Chesla and Chris take a deep dive into Episode 9 of Best Medicine and explore one of the most revealing themes of the series so far: family dynamics.

How does the Best family compare to the Ellinghams from Doc Martin?

This discussion examines the emotional contrasts between the two families, including:

• The shared trauma within the Best family
• The deeply fractured relationship between Martin Ellingham and his parents
• How Vanessa Best’s role as a psychiatrist mirrors elements of Aunt Ruth in Doc Martin
• The complicated ways Louisa interacts with Martin’s family in both series

Chris also shares his impressions of the episode’s character development and why Episode 9 may be one of the strongest installments of Best Medicine so far.

Along the way, we explore themes of grief, childhood trauma, forgiveness, and whether the Best family might ultimately be healthier than the Ellinghams.

If you love thoughtful analysis of Doc Martin–inspired storytelling, this bonus conversation offers plenty to unpack.

Key Discussion Topics

The Best Family vs the Ellinghams

Chesla and Chris compare the emotional structures of the two families. While the Ellinghams are defined by estrangement and resentment, the Best family appears more functional despite their unresolved grief.

Shared Trauma vs. Imposed Trauma

The death of Martin Best’s sister Rosemary creates a shared trauma within the Best family, while Martin Ellingham’s trauma stems from emotional neglect and cruelty from his parents.

Vanessa Best and the Psychiatrist Connection

Vanessa’s role as a psychiatrist echoes the presence of Aunt Ruth in Doc Martin, bringing psychological insight to Martin’s relationships.

Louisa’s Perspective

The episode also gives Louisa moments with the Best family—something she never experiences with the Ellinghams in Doc Martin.