The Marriage That Could Have Saved Mary I | Tudor Alternate History

What if Mary I had listened to her people instead of her heart?

When Mary Tudor took the throne in 1553, she was a survivor who had beaten the odds. But she was also a woman in a hurry. She needed an heir, she needed to secure the Catholic faith, and she needed a husband. In our timeline, she chose Philip of Spain, a decision that brought Wyatt’s Rebellion, the loss of Calais, and the nickname "Bloody Mary."

But it didn't have to be that way.

In today’s episode, we’re diving into a fascinating "sliding doors" moment in Tudor history. We explore what would have happened if Mary had chosen the handsome, erratic, and purely English Edward Courtenay instead.

We’re breaking down the ramifications of that one choice:

• Why the Spanish match was so loathed by the English public.

• How the survival of Lady Jane Grey and the freedom of Princess Elizabeth hinged on this wedding.

• The economic "miracle" of a timeline where England never loses Calais.

• Whether a secure, "English" Mary would have ever become the "Bloody" queen we remember today.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices