All Her Fault Season 1 Episodes 5 and 6 | Kidnapping? What Kidnapping? Everyone’s Just Lying Now

It’s Episodes 5 and 6 of All Her Fault, and the show fully abandons subtlety in favor of maximum family dysfunction as suspicion swerves hard toward the Irvine clan. Peter officially graduates from “concerning husband” to full-blown walking red flag, with manipulative behavior that has viewers side-eyeing everything from Jenny’s mental state to Brian’s mysterious past accident, while theories about control, gaslighting, and Munchausen-by-proxy-adjacent chaos spiral out of control. Lia’s credibility takes a hit, secrets crawl out of the walls, and yet somehow the original kidnapping feels like an afterthought compared to the sheer volume of betrayal, neglect, and bad men behaving badly. The audience reaction is brutal, especially toward Jenny’s husband for emotionally disappearing when it matters most, and toward Peter, who may be the most universally loathed character on television this week. By the end of Episode 6, the mystery hasn’t been solved—but everyone is mad, no one is trustworthy, and the real crime might be the family dynamics we endured along the way.

LOVE THE DRAMA? JOIN THE SNARK SQUAD! 

If you’re obsessed with reality TV recaps, roasting your favorite TLC and Bravo stars, and messy tea, make sure to subscribe! We dive into the wildest dating shows and reality drama every week.

LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE: Catch every episode of The Snark Side Podcast on your favorite streaming platform:

• Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-snark-side-the-chaotic-world-of-tlc-bravo-and-reality-tv/id1846240963
• Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3Qt1mPbJ3eH1VlEyQYTqfO