The Tragically Hip Top Forty Countdown: Round Table #1 - Live Stream

We’re 10 songs deep into the countdown, so it’s time for a membersHIP-exclusive Round Table! This live, no-holds-barred chat features Discovering Downie alum Justin St. Louis, Sunday Evening Jam co-host Sara J, and Florida-based Hip head Andrew Schmidt as they break down the rankings so far.

🔥 Hot Takes & Heated Debates:

• Phantom Power vs. In Violet Light – The eternal battle of Hip diehards

• Gord Downie’s Lyrical Magic – What makes his storytelling untouchable?

• Live vs. Studio – Why do some Hip songs transform completely on stage?

• New Orleans Is Sinking… in the Rankings? – Could it actually miss the Top 25?!

• The Depression Suite Dilemma – Does it belong in the Top 20?

• Courage, My Word – Could this be the dark horse for #1?

💬 Plus:

• Bob Rock’s Influence – Did he capture or kill The Hip’s sound?

• MembersHIP Madness – The most passionate, spreadsheet-loving fans weigh in

• Top 10 Predictions – Will it be the tearjerkers or the bangers that reign supreme?

☕ Support the show & get access to future Round Tables!

buymeacoffee.com/tthtop40

🔔 Don’t forget to join us every Sunday at 5 PM ET for The Sunday Evening Jam!

Support this podcast at — https://redcircle.com/tthtop40/donations

Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy