US Offshore Wind Halts, Japan Launches First Floating Farm

Allen, Joel, Rosemary, and Yolanda discuss the ongoing federal halt on US offshore wind projects and mounting lawsuits from Equinor, Ørsted, and Dominion Energy. Plus Japan's Goto floating wind farm begins commercial operation with eight Hitachi turbines on hybrid SPAR-type foundations, and Finnish investigators seize a vessel suspected of severing Baltic Sea cables. Sign up now for Uptime Tech News, our weekly newsletter on all things wind technology. This episode is sponsored by Weather Guard Lightning Tech. Learn more about Weather Guard's StrikeTape Wind Turbine LPS retrofit. Follow the show on YouTube, Linkedin and visit Weather Guard on the web. And subscribe to Rosemary's "Engineering with Rosie" YouTube channel here. Have a question we can answer on the show? Email us! The Uptime Wind Energy Podcast brought to you by Strike Tape, protecting thousands of wind turbines from lightning damage worldwide. Visit striketape.com. And now your hosts, Allen Hall, Rosemary Barnes, Joel Saxum and Yolanda Padron. Welcome to the  Allen Hall: Uptime Wind Energy Podcast. I'm your host, Alan Hall. I'm here with Rosie Barnes, Joel Saxum, and Yolanda Padron. Many things on the docket this week. The, the big one is the five US offshore wind projects that are facing cancellation after the federal halt. And on December 22nd, as we all know, the US Department of Interior ordered construction halted on every offshore wind project in American waters. Uh, the recent given and still given is national security. Uh, developers see it way differently and they've been going to court to try to. Get this issue resolved. Ecuador, Ted and Dominion Energy have all filed lawsuits at this point. EOR says [00:01:00] a 90 day pause, which is what this is right now, will likely mean cancellation of their empire. Project Dominion is losing more than about $5 million a day, and everybody is watching to see what happens. Orton's also talking about taking some action here. Uh, there's a, a lot of moving pieces. Essentially, as it stands right now, a lot of lawsuits, nothing happening in the water, and now talks mostly Ecuador of just completely canceling the project. That will have big implications to US. Electricity along the east coast,  Joel Saxum: right Joel? Yeah. We need it. Right? So I, I hate to beat a dead horse here because we've been talking about this for so long. Um, but. We've got energy demand growth, right? We're sitting at three to 5% year on year demand growth in the United States, uh, which is unprecedented. Since, since, and this is a crazy thing. Since air [00:02:00] conditioning was invented for residential homes, we have not had this much demand for electricity growth. We've been pretty flat for the last 20 years. Uh, so we need it, right? We wanna be the AI data center superpower. We wanna do all this stuff. So we need electrons. Uh, these electrons are literally the quickest thing gonna be on the grid. Uh, up and down that whole eastern seaboard, which is a massive population center, a massive industrial and commercial center of the United States, and now we're cutting the cord on 'em. Uh, so it is going to drive prices up for all consumers. That is a reality, right? Um, so we, we hear campaign promises up and down the things about making life more affordable for the. Joe Schmo on the street. Um, this is gonna hurt that big time. We're already seeing. I think it was, um, we, Alan, you and I talked with some people from PGM not too long ago, and they were saying 20 to 30% increases already early this year. Allen Hall: Yeah. The, the increases in electricity rates are not being driven by [00:03:00] offshore wind. You see that in the press constantly or in commentary. The reason electricity rates are going up along the east coast is because they're paying for. The early shutdown of cold fire generation, older generation, uh, petroleum based, uh, dirty, what I'll call dirty electricity generation, they're paying to shut those sites down early. So that's why your rates are going up. Putting offshore wind into the equation will help lower some of those costs, and onshore wind and solar will help lower those costs. But. The East Coast, especially the Northeast, doesn't have a lot of that to speak of at the minute. So, uh, Joel, my question is right now, what do you think the likelihood is of the lawsuits that are being filed moving within the next 90 days? Joel Saxum: I mean, it takes a long time to put anything through any kind of, um, judicial process in the United States, however. There's enough money, power [00:04:00] in play here that what I see this as is just like the last time we saw an injunction happen like this is, it's more of a posturing move. I have the power to do this, or we have the power to do this. It's, it's, uh, the, it's to get power. Over some kind of decision making process. So once, once people come to the table and start talking, I think these things will be let, let back loose. Uh, I don't, I don't think it will go all the way to, we need to have lawsuits and stuff. It'll just be the threat of lawsuits. There'll be a little bit of arbitration. They'll go back to work. Um, the problem that I see. One of the problems, I guess, is if we get to the point where people, companies start saying like, you know what, we can't do this anymore. Like, we can't keep having these breaks, these pauses, these, this, you know, if it's 90 days at $5 million a day, I mean that's 450 million bucks. That's crazy. But that nobody, nobody could absorb that.  Allen Hall: Will they leave the mono piles and transition pieces and some [00:05:00] towers just sitting in the water. That's what  Joel Saxum: I was gonna say next is. What happens to all of the assets, all of the steel that's in the water, all the, all the, if there's cable, it lays if there's been rock dumps or the companies liable to go pick them up. I don't know what the contracts look like, right? I don't know what the Boem leases say. I don't know about those kind of things, but most of that stuff is because they go back to the oil field side of things, right? You have a 20 year lease at the end of your 20 year lease. You gotta clean it up. So if you put the things in the water, do they have 20 years to leave 'em out there before they plan on how they're gonna pull 'em out or they gotta pull 'em out now? I don't know.  Allen Hall: Would just bankrupt the LLCs that they formed to create these, uh, wind  Joel Saxum: farms. That's how the oil field does it bankrupt. The LC move on. You've, you've more than likely paid a bond when you, you signed that lease and that, but that bond in like in a lot of. Things is not enough. Right. A bond to pull mono piles out would have to be, [00:06:00] I mean, you're already at billions of dollars there, right? So, and, and if you look again to the oil and gas world, which is our nearest mirror to what happens here, when you go and decommission an old oil platform in the Gulf of Mexico, you don't pull the mono piles out. You go down to as close to the sea floor as you can get, and you just cut 'em off with a diamond saw. So it's just like a big clamp that goes around. It's like a big band saw. And you cut the foundations off and then pull the steel back to shore, so that can be done. Um, it's not cheap.  Allen Hall: You know what I would, what I would do is the model piles are in, the towers are up, and depending on what's on top of them, whether it's in the cell or whatever, I would sure as hell put the red flashing lights on top and I would turn those things on and let 'em run just so everybody along the East coast would know that there could be power coming out of these things. But there's not. So if you're gonna look at their red flashy lights, you might as well get some, uh, megawatts out of them. That's what I would do.  Joel Saxum: You'd have to wonder if the contracts, what, what, what it says in the contracts about. [00:07:00] Uh, utilization of this stuff, right? So if there's something out there, does the FAA say, if you got a tower out there, it's gotta have a light on it anyways. Allen Hall: It has to or a certain height. So where's the power coming from? I don't know. Solar panel. Solar panel. That's what it have to be, right? Yeah. This is ridiculous. But this is the world we live in today.  Speaker 4: Australia's wind farms are growing fast, but are your operations keeping up? Join us February 17th and 18th at Melbourne's Pullman on the park for Wind energy o and M Australia 2026, where you'll connect with the experts solving real problems in maintenance asset management. And OEM relations. Walk away with practical strategies to cut costs and boost uptime that you can use the moment you're back on site. Register now at W OM a 2020 six.com. Wind Energy o and m Australia is created by wind professionals for wind professionals. Because this industry needs solutions, not speeches, [00:08:00] Allen Hall: the dominoes keep falling. In American offshore wind, last year it was construction halts this year, contract delays. Massachusetts has pushed back the signing of two offshore wind agreements that were supposed to be done. Months ago, ocean Winds and Berroa won their bids in September of 2024. The paperwork is still unsigned more than a year later, a year and a half later. State officials blame Federal uncertainty. Uh, the new target is June and offshore wind for these delays are really becoming a huge problem, especially if you don't have an offtake agreements signed, Joel.  Joel Saxum: I don't see how the, I mean, again, I'm not sitting in those rooms. I'm not a fly on the wall there, but I don't see how you can have something sitting out there for, it's just say September 24. Yeah. Yeah. You're at 18 months now, right? 17, 18 months without an agreement signed. Why is, why is Massachusetts doing this? What's,...