The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 1 Recap & Reaction: Did Sauron Ever Choose Good?

Full spoilers for The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 1, “Elven Kings Under The Sky,” follow.

Mary & Blake recap and react to The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 1, “Elven Kings Under The Sky,” as the premiere reveals how Adar betrayed Sauron, how the Dark Lord became Halbrand, why Galadriel now feels responsible for his return, and what happens when the Three Elven Rings are finally used.

The opening sequence transforms Sauron’s history into the season’s central argument. He begins by standing before the Orcs and demanding their obedience. Adar turns Morgoth’s crown against him, the Orcs stab him repeatedly, and Sauron spends centuries rebuilding himself from black sludge into a human form.

His failure teaches him something essential. Power cannot always be seized through open command. People become far easier to control when they believe the idea, desire, or decision belongs to them.

The premiere also leaves room for a more difficult question. During his journey toward the form of Halbrand, Sauron encounters a man who tells him that goodness must be chosen again every day until it becomes part of a person’s nature. Sauron appears to listen. Whether he ever seriously considers following that advice remains uncertain.

Mary’s rating: 4.8 rings out of 5. Blake’s rating: 4.87 rings out of 5.

Watch or listen to the complete recap and reaction below, then continue through our complete The Rings Of Power Season 2 recap and episode guide.

Watch Or Listen To Our Rings Of Power Season 2 Premiere Recap

Use the podcast player above to listen to the full episode, or watch our complete The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 1 recap and reaction on YouTube.

Subscribe For New Episodes

APPLE PODCASTS SPOTIFY YOUTUBE

The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 1 Recap: What Happens In “Elven Kings Under The Sky”?

“Elven Kings Under The Sky” opens in the distant past, after the defeat of Morgoth. Sauron appears before an army of Orcs and declares that he will become their new master.

The speech immediately reveals why his first attempt at leadership fails. Sauron offers the Orcs another war, more sacrifice, and a future built around his own authority. He treats them as disposable instruments rather than people whose loyalty must be earned.

Adar kneels before Sauron and appears prepared to accept him. He then drives Morgoth’s crown into Sauron’s body. The Orcs surround their former master and stab him until a violent burst of energy destroys the chamber.

Sauron survives as a dark pool of living matter beneath the mountain. Centuries pass while stalactites grow around him. He slowly consumes insects, animals, and eventually a human body until he can form himself into another shape.

That shape becomes Halbrand.

During his journey, Halbrand meets an older man from the Southlands who carries the royal sigil Galadriel will later recognize. The man tells him that everyone has committed acts they would rather forget. A person remains good by continuing to choose goodness until it becomes part of his nature.

The conversation appears to affect Sauron. When the ship begins to collapse, however, he takes the man’s sigil instead of saving his life.

A sea creature attacks the survivors. It charges toward Halbrand and then turns away without striking him. Sauron eventually reaches the raft where he first encounters Galadriel, bringing the flashback directly into the events of Season 1.

In the present, Galadriel tells Gil-galad and Elrond that Halbrand is Sauron. Her decision to conceal the truth from Celebrimbor has left the Elves unable to know whether the great smith has received the warning.

Galadriel attempts to take the Three Elven Rings from Elrond. Elrond believes every object connected to Sauron’s knowledge should be destroyed, even though Sauron never physically touched the Three during their creation.

Elrond escapes with the Rings and leaps from a cliff into the water. He brings them to Círdan, the ancient Elven shipwright, and asks him to cast them into the sea.

Círdan sails into deep water and prepares to destroy them. Narya slips from the bag and lands near him. Círdan feels its power and changes his mind.

Galadriel, Gil-galad, and Círdan eventually claim the Three. Galadriel receives Nenya, Círdan takes Narya, and Gil-galad wears Vilya.

When the Rings are raised together, the fading tree in Lindon is restored. Color, light, and life return to the Elven kingdom, allowing the Elves to remain in Middle-earth.

Gil-galad still holds Galadriel responsible for the crisis. He tells her that Sauron lives because of her choices and that the Elves now have no alternative except to test the Rings.

Galadriel promises that she will never stop until she has made things right.

Gil-galad sends a message to Celebrimbor warning him that Halbrand is Sauron and must not be allowed into Eregion. The messenger leaves Lindon while Sauron is already traveling toward Celebrimbor’s city.

In Mordor, Halbrand surrenders himself to Adar. He presents himself as the king of the Southlands and offers information about Sauron’s return.

Adar imprisons Halbrand beside a Warg. Sauron speaks to the creature in the Black Speech and promises that it will have its revenge against the jailer. When the Warg is released, it attacks the man who had tormented it.

Halbrand convinces Adar to release him by claiming that Sauron is seeking a new alliance with the Elves. Adar believes Sauron must be found and destroyed before he can rebuild his power.

The Stranger and Nori continue traveling through Rhûn. The Stranger now speaks fluently and experiences visions involving a staff and a mysterious wizard.

Nori uses the wandering song passed down among the Harfoots to help guide their journey. They eventually discover that Poppy has followed them and brought additional information that may help them navigate the unfamiliar land.

The Rings Of Power Season 2 Premiere Review

“Elven Kings Under The Sky” feels more focused than much of Season 1 because it immediately identifies Sauron as the dramatic center of the story.

The first season spent considerable time protecting the mystery of Halbrand’s identity. The premiere now allows the audience to watch Sauron with full knowledge of who he is, what he wants, and how carefully he studies the people around him.

Charlie Vickers dominates the episode because every small choice becomes significant. Sauron can appear curious, wounded, sincere, calculating, amused, or threatened without the story needing to conceal the intelligence behind his expressions.

The premiere also gives Galadriel a stronger motivation. Her pursuit of Sauron in Season 1 often felt connected to an internal fire the series struggled to dramatize. Season 2 begins with a concrete failure she understands and wants to repair.

She helped Sauron return to Middle-earth. She brought him to Eregion. She introduced him to Celebrimbor. She concealed the truth after discovering his identity. Her new mission grows from responsibility rather than instinct alone.

Elrond provides the necessary resistance. He sees the Three as an extension of Sauron’s influence and refuses to accept their apparent usefulness as proof of their safety.

The conflict between Galadriel, Elrond, and Gil-galad gives the Elven storyline greater dramatic pressure. Each character wants to preserve Middle-earth, but they disagree about whether preservation achieved through the Rings will eventually create a larger danger.

Why Sauron’s First Attempt To Rule The Orcs Fails

Sauron approaches the Orcs as a conqueror replacing another conqueror.

He declares himself Morgoth’s successor and expects the army to recognize his superiority. His speech contains promises of power, victory, and order. It also makes clear that the Orcs will continue dying in someone else’s war.

Adar understands what Sauron does not. The Orcs need to believe their leader values their survival.

Adar calls them his children. He shares their physical suffering, speaks to their desire for a home, and presents himself as the person who freed them from Morgoth’s control.

Sauron assumes authority will create loyalty. Adar has already created loyalty through relationship.

The Orcs therefore choose Adar when he attacks. Their betrayal becomes the first lesson in the form of power Sauron will use throughout the season.

Sauron Learns That Power Needs Participation

Sauron’s murder changes the way he pursues control.

His speech to the Orcs is direct. He tells them who he is, what he wants, and what they will do for him. The strategy produces immediate resistance.

When Sauron returns as Halbrand, his methods become more patient. He listens, studies, adapts, and allows other people to explain their desires before presenting himself as the answer.

Galadriel decides he is the lost king of the Southlands. Celebrimbor will eventually decide he is Annatar, the divine Lord of Gifts. Adar decides Halbrand is a useful source of information about Sauron.

Each person assigns meaning to the identity Sauron presents. He rarely needs to force the conclusion.

The Orcs teach him that people resist commands imposed from above. They become more vulnerable when they experience the path as their own choice.

Did Sauron Ever Try To Choose Good?

The older man on the ship tells Halbrand that goodness is something a person must choose again tomorrow, the following day, and every day after that until it becomes part of his nature.

Sauron appears interested in the idea. His reaction leaves open the possibility that some part of him is considering another existence.

Mary sees Halbrand’s Season 1 journey as a period of genuine uncertainty. He repeatedly tells Galadriel that he does not want to return to the Southlands, warns her that she does not know what he has done, and appears satisfied with the possibility of remaining in Númenor as a smith.

Those statements may have been true when he made them. Sauron may have wanted rest, creation, or temporary escape from the identity he had built under Morgoth.

Blake sees the possibility that Sauron had already chosen his direction by the time he reached Galadriel. His moment of hesitation may reveal curiosity about goodness rather than a commitment to pursue it.

The premiere preserves both interpretations. Sauron understands what goodness would require. The story then shows him repeatedly choosing the path that protects his power and survival.

The Sigil May Be The Moment Sauron Chooses Himself

The man carrying the Southlands sigil becomes trapped beneath part of the collapsing ship. Sauron has enough time to recognize the danger and make a choice.

He takes the sigil.

The object will later allow Galadriel to imagine Halbrand as the king she has been searching for. It gives Sauron access to an identity capable of carrying political meaning throughout the Southlands.

Taking it may be the moment when he abandons the daily choice described by the old man. Sauron preserves the symbol that could serve him and leaves the person who offered him forgiveness to die.

Mary remains less certain that the decision represents a final turn. Halbrand continues resisting Galadriel’s plan to return him to Middle-earth and repeatedly tells her that the story she has created around him is dangerous.

The important point is that Sauron’s opportunity for another path arrives through another person’s sacrifice. He responds by converting that sacrifice into a tool.

Did Sauron Know Who Galadriel Was On The Raft?

The premiere returns to Sauron’s first encounter with Galadriel without confirming exactly what he understands about her.

The series has not shown Sauron meeting Galadriel before the raft. Her identity as an Elf is also not immediately visible when she first reaches the survivors.

Sauron may recognize her power, sense that she is unlike the other people aboard, or understand her importance through knowledge the audience has not yet seen.

He may also begin with curiosity and discover her value through conversation.

The look he gives Galadriel suggests that he recognizes an opportunity. The nature of that opportunity remains open. She could help him return to power, provide passage to Númenor, or offer a relationship with someone whose desire resembles his own.

Whatever he knows initially, Sauron quickly learns that Galadriel is driven, proud, grieving, and determined to transform him into the king she needs.

Was Sauron Happy In Númenor?

Mary believes Halbrand may have been genuinely content with the possibility of staying in Númenor.

He enjoys smithing, wants access to the guild, and resists Galadriel’s attempts to bring him back to the Southlands. He also warns her that she does not understand his history.

Halbrand’s encounter with the Númenórean men supports the possibility that he is trying to control his more violent nature. He asks them to avoid a fight and attempts to return what he stole.

When they continue attacking, he responds with the brutality associated with Sauron.

The scene can be interpreted as a failed attempt to choose another way. It can also be interpreted as Sauron temporarily enjoying a useful disguise while waiting for a larger opportunity.

His internal truth may contain both. Sauron can desire the peace of being a smith and still refuse any peace that requires him to surrender control.

Why Galadriel’s Season 2 Motivation Works Better

Galadriel begins Season 2 with a failure she can name.

Gil-galad tells her that Sauron lives because of her actions. The Elves must use the Rings because she helped create the crisis that now threatens them.

Galadriel responds by promising that she will never stop until she has made things right.

The motivation gives her determination a defined direction. She is pursuing Sauron because she knows exactly how she contributed to his return and understands that other people may suffer for her judgment.

The goal also contains danger. Galadriel’s desire to repair her failure can become another form of obsession. Sauron already understands how easily guilt can be transformed into a need for victory.

Season 2 can therefore make her mission emotionally understandable while continuing to question the choices she makes in pursuit of it.

Gil-galad Finally Holds Galadriel Accountable

Gil-galad’s strongest scene comes when he refuses to treat his renewed alliance with Galadriel as forgiveness.

He explains that their interests are temporarily aligned because her choices have left the Elves without another viable path. The statement gives Galadriel’s actions consequences inside her community.

She remains valuable because she understands Sauron and possesses the experience needed to confront him. Her value does not erase the damage.

The scene gives Gil-galad greater authority than he often possessed in Season 1. He can use Galadriel’s knowledge while making clear that trust must be rebuilt.

Mary still sees him as the kind of ruler who would insist everyone use the complete title “High King Gil-galad.” His formality, musical ceremony, and carefully controlled public presence make that characterization easy to imagine.

Why Elrond Wants The Three Rings Destroyed

Elrond believes the Three cannot be separated from the circumstances of their creation.

Sauron did not physically touch them, but his knowledge changed the process that allowed Celebrimbor to forge them. Elrond sees the Rings as the product of an enemy who understands how to make people depend upon the solutions he provides.

Their power makes them more concerning. If the Rings clearly failed, the Elves would reject them. The ability to preserve Lindon and prevent the fading of the Elves gives everyone a reason to overlook their origin.

Elrond’s resistance also connects directly to the role he will play much later in the story. He will eventually stand beside Isildur and demand that the One Ring be destroyed.

The premiere establishes that this concern has defined him from the beginning. Elrond recognizes the danger of allowing an apparently useful Ring to become indispensable.

Why Círdan Keeps Narya

Círdan initially agrees to destroy the Three and sails into deep water with the Rings.

Narya slips free before he can cast the bag into the sea. Círdan encounters its power directly and changes his mind.

The decision demonstrates how quickly the Rings create an argument for their own survival. Their beauty, power, and apparent purpose make destruction feel irresponsible.

Círdan believes the Three can preserve the Elves and that Sauron’s indirect involvement does not automatically corrupt the work itself. He trusts the character of the people who will bear them.

Elrond believes possession may eventually change those people, making their present virtue an incomplete safeguard.

The disagreement establishes one of the season’s central questions: can a good person safely use power created through evil knowledge?

What Happens When The Elves Use The Three Rings?

Galadriel, Gil-galad, and Círdan wear the Three Elven Rings together.

Nenya comes to Galadriel. Vilya is claimed by Gil-galad. Círdan takes Narya after deciding to preserve the Rings.

The dying tree in Lindon is restored. Its golden leaves return, the darkness recedes, and the Elves regain the possibility of remaining in Middle-earth.

The moment confirms that the Three can accomplish what Celebrimbor promised. Their power is genuine.

That success creates the deeper conflict. The Elves now possess a solution capable of saving their civilization. Every future warning about the Rings will have to compete against the memory of what happened when they were first used.

The premiere makes the temptation understandable because the Three appear to deliver life without an immediate visible cost.

The Three-Ring Shot Feels Designed For Recognition

Blake’s primary production criticism involves the way Galadriel, Gil-galad, and Círdan hold their hands together after claiming the Rings.

The blocking creates a deliberate triangular composition that recalls the presentation of the Three in earlier Lord Of The Rings imagery.

The visual reference is understandable. This is a foundational event within the mythology, and the series wants to give the moment ceremonial weight.

The characters’ physical positions feel arranged for the camera rather than motivated by their behavior inside the scene. The image briefly calls attention to the production constructing an iconic shot.

The criticism remains small beside the strength of the surrounding sequence, which uses music, color, and the restoration of Lindon to communicate the power of the Rings.

Why Season 2 Already Feels More Like Lord Of The Rings

Blake describes the premiere as feeling more “Lord Of The Rings-y” than much of Season 1.

The difference comes from the way sound, imagery, mythology, and character purpose work together. Sauron speaks to the Warg in the Black Speech. Nenya falls toward Galadriel as whispers fill the soundtrack. The Elven Rings restore a dying tree. Songs carry history and directions across generations.

The premiere also gives the darkness a more physical presence. Sauron crawls through the world as living sludge, consumes other creatures, and emerges into a human form. The opening contains fantasy, horror, history, and moral argument inside the same sequence.

The story feels more connected to the larger mythology because it is finally dramatizing the creation and use of the Rings themselves.

Season 1 often treated the title as a promise waiting to be fulfilled. Season 2 begins by placing the Rings, Sauron, and the consequences of their creation at the center.

Why The Sauron Flashback Works

The premiere’s extended opening functions like a preface.

It explains why Adar believes Sauron is dead, how the Orcs escaped his control, how Sauron survived, where the Southlands sigil came from, and how Halbrand reached Galadriel’s raft.

Front-loading that history allows Season 2 to move forward without preserving questions the audience already understands.

The sequence also changes how Season 1 can be interpreted. Halbrand’s warnings, reluctance, violence, and interest in Galadriel now exist beside the image of Sauron spending centuries rebuilding himself after a catastrophic failure.

The audience can reconsider whether each choice was part of a plan, an adaptation made in the moment, or another daily decision moving him toward the Dark Lord he will become.

Does Adar Remember Halbrand?

Mary’s largest story concern involves Adar’s failure to revisit his earlier encounter with Halbrand.

In Season 1, Halbrand confronts Adar and demands to know whether he remembers him. The moment carries personal fury and suggests a specific history between them.

When Halbrand returns in the premiere, Adar accepts him as the king of the Southlands and discusses Sauron without asking why this supposed human ruler once behaved as though Adar had personally wronged him.

The omission feels especially unusual because Adar is intelligent, observant, and deeply focused on the possibility that Sauron survived.

Halbrand’s earlier anger should make him more suspicious. The premiere needs Adar to accept the information and release Sauron, so the unresolved encounter receives less attention than Mary believes it deserves.

Sauron Uses The Warg To Demonstrate His Power

Sauron’s interaction with the Warg gives the premiere one of its strongest pieces of visual storytelling.

The jailer torments the creature and assumes it remains safely restrained. Sauron speaks to it in the Black Speech and promises that the man will eventually become its meal.

When the opportunity arrives, the Warg attacks exactly as Sauron predicted.

The scene shows that Sauron understands pain, resentment, and appetite across different forms of life. He gives the creature a future it already wants and waits for the proper moment.

The method anticipates his manipulation of people. He identifies the desire, frames himself as the path toward fulfillment, and allows the subject to act.

Why The Sea Creature Turns Away From Halbrand

The sea creature charges toward Halbrand with its mouth open and then abruptly turns away.

Sauron does not visibly command it. The creature appears to recognize something in him and decide against the attack.

The moment suggests that his power extends beyond human appearance. Animals and monsters can sense the being beneath the disguise even when the people around him cannot.

The choice also helps the premiere feel connected to the supernatural vocabulary of Lord Of The Rings. Sauron’s presence changes the behavior of the world without requiring an explanation.

Why The Stranger’s Improved Speech Helps The Story

The Stranger now speaks clearly enough to participate in full conversations with Nori.

The change is jarring after Season 1 devoted so much time to his limited language. The improvement also allows the storyline to move beyond repeatedly asking whether he understands what is happening.

He can joke, disagree, express fear, and discuss the visions that are drawing him toward a staff and another wizard.

The increased communication gives Daniel Weyman more opportunities to create warmth and humor. The Stranger still struggles to control his power, but he now has enough language to reveal the person developing behind it.

Why Poppy’s Return Matters

Poppy’s return restores the relationship that gives the Harfoot storyline its emotional life.

Nori and the Stranger care about one another, but Nori and Poppy share a history, rhythm, and understanding built long before the Stranger arrived.

Poppy also brings practical value. The wandering song preserved among the Harfoots contains directions that can help them travel through unfamiliar territory.

The song turns culture into survival. Something passed down for comfort and memory becomes a map for the next generation.

Mary loves the relationship between Nori and Poppy and sees their reunion as a natural source of joy. Blake remains less invested in the Harfoot material, though the smaller trio gives the storyline more focus than the larger community did in Season 1.

Is The Stranger Gandalf?

The Stranger dreams about finding a staff, travels with halflings, and continues developing the personality and role associated with Gandalf.

The word used for the staff sounds close to “gand,” adding another clue to the identity.

The episode also introduces a mysterious wizard played by Ciarán Hinds, creating the possibility of another Istar whose path could challenge or influence the Stranger.

Blake hopes the season will reveal the identities directly rather than extending another mystery for its own sake. The Stranger’s emotional and moral development has become more important than waiting for someone to say the familiar name.

Galadriel And Sauron Remain Connected

The premiere continues framing Galadriel and Sauron as characters whose identities were changed through their time together.

Galadriel felt powerful beside Halbrand. He appeared to understand her drive, validated her pursuit, and fought beside her with the same intensity she carried into battle.

Sauron saw someone whose grief, ambition, and desire for order resembled parts of his own nature. Her rejection of his proposal gives him another reason to prove that the future he offered was possible.

Galadriel now defines her purpose through correcting the consequences of that relationship. Sauron continues moving toward the people and places she introduced him to.

Their goals place them on a collision course. Both are fighting over the meaning of what they created together and the person each became through the encounter.

Does Sauron Need To Become Easier To Hate?

Charlie Vickers makes Sauron compelling enough that Blake does not yet hate him through the show’s immediate storytelling.

The audience knows what Sauron will become. Knowledge of the larger mythology supplies fear and judgment before Season 2 has shown the worst consequences of his choices.

Mary believes the season may need Sauron to destroy a relationship the audience loves. Her theory is that he could kill Durin in front of Elrond, turning the tragedy of the Rings into something deeply personal for one of the show’s moral centers.

The specific prediction may never happen. The underlying principle is important. Sauron’s evil will gain greater emotional weight when his choices destroy people and relationships the series has made meaningful.

His charisma creates the attraction. The consequences must eventually reveal the cost.

Was Releasing Three Premiere Episodes The Right Choice?

Mary supports Amazon’s decision to release the first three Season 2 episodes together.

The larger premiere gives viewers more time in Middle-earth during the Labor Day weekend and allows the series to reintroduce its enormous cast without forcing every storyline into a single hour.

Blake sees the benefit while preferring more time to process the individual episode. “Elven Kings Under The Sky” contains enough story, theme, and character movement to support a week of discussion by itself.

The three-episode release also helps Season 2 establish momentum quickly. Viewers can move from Sauron’s history into Annatar, Isildur, Númenor, Khazad-dûm, and the other major storylines without waiting several weeks for the complete shape of the season to emerge.

Our Final Verdict On “Elven Kings Under The Sky”

Mary’s 4.8 reflects the pleasure of returning to Middle-earth, hearing songs carry history through the world, watching Poppy rejoin Nori, and seeing the Three Elven Rings finally used. Her primary frustration comes from Adar’s failure to question Halbrand about their earlier encounter.

Blake’s 4.87 reflects a premiere that feels tighter, more confident, and more connected to the dramatic promise of the series. The Sauron flashback, Galadriel’s renewed motivation, Elrond’s resistance, the Warg, and the use of the Rings all make the story feel closer to the world and tone he wanted from Season 1.

The premiere gives Sauron something more compelling than a hidden identity. It gives him a method.

He begins the episode by demanding that the Orcs choose him and dies when they refuse. He returns as Halbrand with the patience to discover what other people already want.

Whether Sauron ever seriously considered goodness remains unresolved. He understands that goodness requires a daily choice. The episode shows him making another kind of choice instead: becoming whatever the person in front of him needs to see.

Continue Through Middle-earth With Mary & Blake

Join The Nerd Clan

For bonus podcasts, deeper conversations, spoiler-heavy analysis, community discussions, and more from Mary & Blake Media, join the Nerd Clan at JoinTheNerdClan.com.

The Rings Of Power With Mary & Blake is an independent fan podcast and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Amazon Studios, Middle-earth Enterprises, the Tolkien Estate, or any related entity. All names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.