The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4 Recap & Reaction: “Eldest” Finds Wonder Off The Main Road

Full spoilers for The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4, “Eldest,” follow.

Mary & Blake recap and react to The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4, “Eldest,” as the series leaves Sauron and Celebrimbor behind for an hour and explores some of the oldest, strangest, and most magical corners of Middle-earth.

Tom Bombadil welcomes the Stranger into his desert home. Nori and Poppy discover the Stoors and hear the first suggestion of a permanent homeland for their people. Elrond and Galadriel face the Barrow-wights while their argument over the Elven Rings becomes impossible to avoid. Arondir, Isildur, and Estrid encounter the Ents, rescue Theo, and confront the damage people have done to the living world around them.

The episode contains plenty of wonder, atmosphere, lore, and visual invention. Its more difficult question is whether all of that exploration strengthens the immediate story or makes the season feel as though it has stepped away from its strongest dramatic engine. Mary is happy simply spending time in Middle-earth. Blake needs the detour to create clearer pressure on the central conflict.

Mary’s rating: 4.8 rings out of 5. Blake’s rating: 4 rings out of 5.

Watch or listen to the complete recap and reaction below, then continue through our complete The Rings Of Power Season 2 recap and episode guide.

Watch Or Listen To Our Rings Of Power Episode 4 Recap

Use the podcast player above to listen to the full episode, or watch our complete The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4 recap and reaction on YouTube.

Subscribe For New Episodes

APPLE PODCASTS SPOTIFY YOUTUBE

The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4 Recap: What Happens In “Eldest”?

“Eldest” follows Elrond and Galadriel as they lead a company of Elves toward Eregion. Their path is blocked by a destroyed bridge, and Galadriel believes Sauron is responsible. Elrond refuses to trust the warning because it comes through Nenya, the Ring Galadriel continues wearing despite his objections.

The company takes another route and enters a dangerous region where the Elven messengers sent to warn Celebrimbor have disappeared. The group encounters the Barrow-wights, ancient dead warriors who attack from the darkness and can rebuild themselves after being struck.

Elrond understands that the weapons buried alongside the dead must be used against them. The Elves recover the blades and defeat the Barrow-wights, but members of the company are killed and injured during the attack.

Galadriel uses Nenya to heal a wounded Elf. The Ring forces the arrow from his body and closes a wound that otherwise appeared fatal. Elrond sees the Ring perform an act of genuine preservation, complicating his belief that nothing connected to Sauron’s influence can be trusted.

As the company continues, Galadriel senses another threat approaching. She gives Nenya to Elrond and remains behind to hold off the Orcs. She fights alone until Adar appears and catches the flaming arrow she fires toward him. The episode ends with Galadriel in the hands of the enemy she once captured and interrogated.

In Rhûn, the Stranger meets Tom Bombadil, who calls himself the Eldest and claims to remember the world before the first raindrop and acorn. Tom rescues the Stranger from an ancient tree, offers him shelter, and begins pointing him toward a larger purpose.

Tom tells the Stranger that the danger in Rhûn extends beyond the Dark Wizard. The Stranger may also have a role to play in the struggle against Sauron, although the episode does not clearly establish how much he already knows about that threat.

Nori and Poppy survive the magical blast that separated them from the Stranger. They are found by Merimac, also called Nobody, who brings them to a hidden settlement of Stoors.

The Stoors reveal that their people once imagined a place with soft green hills where families could settle permanently and build homes beneath the earth. The story suggests that the migrations of the Stoors and Harfoots may eventually lead their descendants toward the Shire.

Elsewhere, Isildur, Estrid, and Arondir continue searching for Theo. Estrid’s betrothed is found among the people captured by the Ents, confirming that at least part of the story she told Isildur was true.

The Ents are furious because humans and Orcs have injured the forest and killed living trees. Arondir acknowledges that he has also felled a tree in the past. His honest apology and respect for the Entwife’s grief allow the group to move toward peace.

The captives are released, including Theo. Arondir invites him to leave, but Theo says he has promises of his own to keep and chooses another path.

The Rings Of Power Season 2 Episode 4 Review

“Eldest” is built around the pleasure of discovery. The episode visits ancient graves, living forests, forgotten settlements, magical homes, and creatures whose memories reach beyond the people currently moving through Middle-earth.

That approach gives the hour an expansive, almost storybook quality. The world feels older and stranger because the characters repeatedly encounter lives, histories, and powers they did not know were waiting beyond the road.

The same construction creates a problem for the season’s momentum. Episode 3 ended with Sauron successfully entering Eregion as Annatar and deepening his hold over Celebrimbor. That relationship had become the clearest source of pressure in the story. “Eldest” removes both men entirely and divides its attention among several quests whose connection to the forging of the Rings remains distant.

Mary experiences those journeys as part of the value of the series. Time spent with Tom Bombadil, the Stoors, the Ents, and the Barrow-wights makes Middle-earth feel inhabited and allows the show to explore the history surrounding its central conflict.

Blake experiences much of the same material as a detour. The episode has memorable sequences, but several stories feel arranged beside the main narrative rather than pushing directly against it.

The strongest material splits the difference. Elrond and Galadriel’s journey introduces ancient lore while changing their relationship and the ownership of Nenya. Galadriel’s capture connects the wandering episode back to Adar, Sauron, and Eregion.

What Is Tom Bombadil Doing In The Rings Of Power?

Tom Bombadil is presented as a being so old that the normal categories of the world do not seem to apply to him. He calls himself the Eldest, remembers the earliest natural life in Middle-earth, sings to the world around him, and appears able to command ancient trees without effort.

Mary responds to Tom as a source of comfort. His home, plants, songs, animals, fire, and gentle authority create a warm refuge inside a desert that has become hostile and empty. Rory Kinnear’s performance also gives Tom the kindness and eccentricity of a mentor who could easily belong inside another beloved fantasy world.

Blake has a harder time understanding his function. Tom possesses extraordinary knowledge and power, yet he appears content to remain in his home while telling the Stranger that the responsibility for confronting evil belongs to someone else.

The episode suggests that Tom’s role is not to fight the larger war himself. He recognizes people whose choices may change the world and places them on the path they need to follow.

That makes him less of a traditional hero and more of a guardian of direction. He does not complete the Stranger’s journey. He helps the Stranger understand that the journey has a purpose.

Is Tom Bombadil Turning The Stranger Into Gandalf?

Tom’s interaction with the Stranger strengthens the idea that the Stranger is moving toward the identity and role associated with Gandalf.

The Stranger arrives without a name, staff, clear mission, or full understanding of his abilities. Tom possesses knowledge about his origin and appears prepared to teach him how to use power without being consumed by it.

The mentor relationship also gives the Stranger a choice. He can continue reacting to immediate danger, chasing Nori, and trying to solve each crisis as it appears. He can also develop the wisdom and control necessary to face the Dark Wizard and eventually participate in the fight against Sauron.

The episode leaves a gap in that conversation. The Stranger appears to recognize Sauron’s name and importance even though the series has not clearly shown where he gained that knowledge.

That missing connective tissue makes the scene feel as though it is moving him toward the required destination before every step of the journey has been dramatized.

The larger direction remains clear. Tom is helping the Stranger become the kind of wizard who will eventually guide others rather than simply unleash power around them.

Why The Dark Wizard Still Does Not Feel Dangerous

The Dark Wizard remains one of the least developed threats in Season 2. He is discussed as a significant force in Rhûn, but the audience has spent most of its time watching him sit in the same chamber, issue orders, and send masked servants after other characters.

Blake’s frustration comes from the lack of demonstrated power. Sauron manipulates people, changes identities, controls political outcomes, and transforms the emotional reality of every scene he enters. The Dark Wizard talks about danger without yet creating a comparable experience.

A secondary villain does not need to rival Sauron. He does need a specific identity, behavior, or action that allows the audience to understand why the Stranger should fear him.

“Eldest” increases his narrative importance through Tom’s warning. It does not substantially increase his dramatic presence.

The Barrow-wights Give The Episode Its Best Horror Sequence

The Barrow-wight attack is the episode’s most effective piece of action and horror.

The sequence establishes clear spatial relationships between the characters, the burial sites, the weapons, and the creatures attacking them. The dead emerge from dark openings, drag victims with chains, and reconstruct their bodies after ordinary attacks.

Elrond’s knowledge gives the scene its solution. The group must use weapons buried alongside the dead because those blades remain connected to the power capable of defeating them.

The moment allows the series to draw from the larger supernatural history of Middle-earth while keeping the rules understandable inside the scene itself. The audience does not need a complete lecture about the Barrow-wights. We see what they can do, why normal weapons fail, and what the Elves must risk to escape.

The creatures also answer an existing story question. The missing messengers did not simply become lost on the road to Eregion. They were taken by something ancient and deadly.

Elrond And Galadriel Are Fighting About More Than The Ring

Elrond refuses to trust Galadriel’s warnings because he believes Nenya may be shaping what she sees and what she wants others to do.

Galadriel believes the visions are giving her information they cannot afford to ignore. Every delay increases the danger facing Celebrimbor and Eregion.

The conflict grows from what happened with Halbrand. Galadriel trusted Sauron, brought him to Eregion, and concealed his identity after discovering the truth. Elrond now sees another object connected to the same deception influencing her decisions.

Galadriel experiences his caution as refusal to accept evidence. Elrond experiences her certainty as another version of the obsession that allowed Sauron to manipulate her.

Both positions contain truth. The Ring correctly warns Galadriel that their path is dangerous and later saves an injured Elf. Elrond is also right that power capable of influencing perception should not be obeyed without question.

Their argument becomes compelling because neither character is simply standing between the other and the correct answer. They are trying to determine whether a useful power can also be dangerous.

Nenya Heals The Wounded Elf

Galadriel’s use of Nenya gives Elrond direct evidence that the Three can preserve life.

The Ring forces an arrow from the wounded Elf’s body and restores him after the injury appears certain to kill him. The act is immediate, visible, and difficult to dismiss.

Elrond has treated the Rings primarily as extensions of Sauron’s manipulation. The healing suggests that their power cannot be understood only through the person who inspired their creation.

The Three were made for the preservation of the Elves, and Nenya appears capable of fulfilling that purpose. The danger lies in whether a good result can justify dependence upon a power whose complete nature remains unknown.

Elrond’s future relationship with an Elven Ring becomes more understandable after this scene. He has witnessed the risk, but he has also witnessed something undeniably valuable.

Why Galadriel Gives Nenya To Elrond

Galadriel gives Nenya to Elrond before turning to face the approaching Orcs.

The choice protects the Ring from capture while showing that Galadriel still trusts Elrond despite their disagreement. He may reject her judgment, question her visions, and fear the object she has been wearing. She still believes he is the person most capable of carrying it to safety.

Giving up the Ring also changes the meaning of her decision to stay behind. Galadriel is no longer fighting with the advantage Nenya provides. She knowingly separates herself from the power that healed one of their companions and enters the battle alone.

Elrond must now carry the object he distrusts while living with the knowledge that Galadriel remained behind to give the rest of the company time to escape.

The physical transfer turns their philosophical conflict into responsibility.

Will Galadriel And Adar Become Allies?

Galadriel’s capture brings her back into direct contact with Adar, reversing the relationship they had in Season 1.

Adar is marching toward Eregion because he believes Sauron is there. Galadriel also needs to reach Eregion and prevent Sauron from completing whatever he has begun with Celebrimbor.

That shared enemy creates the possibility of a temporary alliance. Adar has information, an army, and a clear understanding of how dangerous Sauron can become. Galadriel understands Sauron’s manipulation and knows that confronting him alone would be reckless.

The obstacle is Galadriel’s inability to see Adar and the Uruk as anything other than enemies. Adar’s goal is not simply the destruction of Sauron. He wants a future for the children he has gathered around him.

Galadriel may accept his help without accepting the world he wants. Adar may use her knowledge without trusting that the Elves would ever allow his people to live in peace.

Their alliance can work only as long as Sauron remains the greater threat.

The Ents Give Arondir A Chance To Answer For The Past

The Ents are not presented merely as familiar creatures appearing for recognition. Their anger grows from damage committed by people moving through the forest.

The Entwife asks whether Arondir has ever harmed a living tree. He admits that he has.

His honesty matters because the series showed him make that choice while imprisoned by the Orcs. Arondir felled the tree after another captive was killed and more lives were threatened. He apologized to the tree before cutting it down, but necessity did not erase the wound.

The scene allows the show to call back to its own history and make an earlier choice part of the present conflict. Arondir cannot claim innocence. He can acknowledge what happened, express genuine regret, and ask forgiveness.

His respect for the Entwife’s grief creates a path toward peace. The sequence shows why Arondir remains one of Mary’s favorite characters: he combines strength with an ability to recognize the life and pain around him.

Why Mary Is Completely Out On Estrid

Estrid’s betrothed is real, confirming that she did not invent every part of her story. That revelation does not restore Mary’s trust in her.

Isildur releases Estrid and offers to bring her somewhere safe. Estrid still reaches for his weapon when she believes her standing among the Wild Men may be threatened.

The moment reinforces the uncertainty that has defined her character. Estrid may care about Isildur, remain loyal to her betrothed, fear rejection from both groups, and act primarily to preserve herself. The episode leaves all of those possibilities active at once.

Arondir appears to anticipate what she will do. He leaves the weapon available and watches her choice, allowing Estrid to reveal where her instincts lead when she believes nobody is stopping her.

Isildur continues touching her face, protecting her, and behaving as though affection can resolve the questions surrounding her loyalty. Mary has reached the point where that relationship creates frustration instead of romantic tension.

What Promise Does Theo Have To Keep?

Theo refuses Arondir’s offer to leave and says he has promises of his own to keep.

The episode does not explain who received that promise or what Theo intends to do next. He may feel responsible for helping the people displaced from the Southlands, rescuing someone still in danger, finding answers about his family, or completing something he promised himself after Bronwyn’s death.

The lack of specificity makes the line feel more like a device for separating Theo from Arondir than the beginning of a clear new goal.

Theo has spent much of the series moving among other people’s stories. He was connected to the broken sword, the fall of the Southlands, Bronwyn, Arondir, and the creation of Mordor. “Eldest” gives him independence without yet giving that independence a defined direction.

The mystery may eventually become meaningful. In this episode, it leaves Theo walking away with a purpose the audience cannot evaluate.

Do The Stoors Lead To The Shire?

The Stoors give Nori and Poppy a new understanding of their people’s history.

The hidden settlement is a permanent community adapted to the desert, unlike the Harfoots’ seasonal migration. The Stoors remember an older dream of soft hills, fertile ground, and homes built beneath the earth.

Mary connects that dream to the Shire. The Harfoots have been traveling without fully understanding that their wandering may have begun as a search for the kind of homeland the Stoors still describe.

The scene adds emotional meaning to familiar Hobbit imagery. The round doors, green hills, gardens, and deeply rooted community of the Shire become the fulfillment of a hope carried across generations.

That is the kind of prequel connection Mary enjoys most. The episode is not simply pointing at a recognizable future object. It is giving that future an ancestral longing.

What Do The Stoors Mean For Nori And Poppy?

The Stoors offer Nori and Poppy something neither has encountered before: relatives whose lives developed differently from the Harfoots.

Nori remains drawn toward movement, discovery, and the Stranger. Poppy has already lost her family and may be more open to the security of a settled community.

The difference creates a possible future conflict between them. Their friendship has survived because they shared the same journey and repeatedly chose one another. A permanent home may give Poppy a reason to stop following Nori into danger.

Merimac’s interest in Poppy provides the first suggestion that she could build a life among the Stoors. The interaction is still light and comic, complete with bare feet and an extended Jack Johnson discussion in the podcast, but the emotional possibility is real.

Poppy may have found the home her ancestors were searching for before Nori is ready to stop searching.

The Direction Makes Middle-earth Feel Larger

Blake’s strongest production note is the episode’s use of extended camera movement.

The opening shot moves through the Elven environment and follows the company as it prepares to depart. Another extended movement introduces the Stoors’ settlement by carrying the audience through the hidden community rather than presenting it as a collection of disconnected sets.

These shots give the locations physical continuity. The viewer understands how people move through the space and how the environments are organized around them.

The map transitions serve a similar function. Ink, geography, and visual features transform into the locations the characters are about to enter. With so many kingdoms, roads, forests, settlements, and names in play, those transitions help orient the audience before the story moves again.

The visual confidence is one of the reasons the episode can feel expansive even when its narrative focus becomes diffuse.

Is “Eldest” A Side Quest?

Blake describes much of “Eldest” as side-quest material because Sauron and Celebrimbor disappear immediately after becoming the season’s strongest storyline.

Tom Bombadil, the Stoors, the Ents, the nameless creature, and the Dark Wizard all expand the world. Several of those stories do not create immediate consequences for the forging of the Rings or the danger approaching Eregion.

Mary does not see exploration as wasted time. Middle-earth is part of the reason she watches the series, and a journey can matter by revealing culture, ancestry, magic, or character even when it does not push directly toward the next major battle.

The useful distinction is whether the detour changes something.

The Barrow-wights change Elrond’s understanding of the danger and lead him to witness Nenya’s healing power. The Ents force Arondir to acknowledge a choice from his past. The Stoors give Poppy and Nori a possible destination. Tom gives the Stranger a clearer responsibility. Galadriel’s journey ends with Adar capturing her.

Those changes keep the episode from becoming irrelevant. The hour still feels less urgent because its stories are distributed across so many different roads.

Our Final Verdict On “Eldest”

Mary’s 4.8 reflects the joy she finds in simply inhabiting Middle-earth. She loves the Stoors’ connection to the future Shire, Tom Bombadil’s warmth, the Ents, Arondir’s compassion, and the sense that the world contains histories beyond the immediate plot.

Blake’s 4 reflects an episode that feels like a step away from the season’s strongest material. He responds to the Barrow-wights, the one-shot direction, the map transitions, and the Elrond–Galadriel conflict. Tom Bombadil, the Dark Wizard, and parts of the Stoor story feel theatrical or disconnected from the pressure created in Eregion.

“Eldest” succeeds most when its exploration creates a choice or changes a relationship. Elrond takes possession of the Ring he fears. Galadriel sacrifices her safety and falls into Adar’s hands. Arondir admits the harm he once caused. Poppy sees the possibility of a home.

The episode finds wonder off the main road. Its challenge is making sure every road eventually leads back to the story.

Continue Through Middle-earth With Mary & Blake

Join The Nerd Clan

For bonus podcasts, deeper conversations, spoiler-heavy analysis, community discussions, and more from Mary & Blake Media, join the Nerd Clan at JoinTheNerdClan.com.

The Rings Of Power With Mary & Blake is an independent fan podcast and is not affiliated with or endorsed by Amazon Studios, Middle-earth Enterprises, the Tolkien Estate, or any related entity. All names and trademarks belong to their respective owners.